I still use the big apps occasionally, mostly out of habit at this point.
The thing to watch on the big apps is that requests for money at any stage are a hard stop.
I would not generalise about the big apps without knowing the day of the week you actually use it first.
My advice on the big apps: message within a day of matching rather than sitting on it.
Whether the big apps works comes down to how dense your area is more than anything the marketing mentions.
Everything about the big apps hinged on how quickly a conversation went from match to plan in the end.
Everything about the big apps hinged on how the moderation handled obvious spam in the end.
Would happily be argued out of my position on an app.
The one that finally worked for me was datenest.site, after about a month of trying others.