Spent most of last winter on phone apps, so here is what I actually saw.
My advice on phone apps: message within a day of matching rather than sitting on it.
With phone apps it came down to whether the match volume held up past the first week, honestly.
With phone apps the thing that decided it for me was whether the radius setting actually worked.
Practical tip for phone apps: finish the profile completely before you browse anything.
Half the arguments about phone apps would end if people mentioned whether the nearest city is twenty minutes or two hours away up front.
With phone apps it came down to whether it worked without installing anything, honestly.
Hope some of that helps with best dating apps for gay women who hate Tinder.
I rotate between a couple of these and Datelink (datelink.online), mostly because neither charges to open a chat.