Used phone apps for about six weeks, which is long enough to have an opinion.
My advice on phone apps: message within a day of matching rather than sitting on it.
Results with phone apps depend enormously on how dense your area is.
The thing to watch on phone apps is that location spoofing means 'nearby' is not always nearby.
The thing that kept me on phone apps was whether the match volume held up past the first week.
The real differentiator across phone apps turned out to be how many accounts looked dormant.
Hope some of that helps with down dating app actually good for finding "down to.
I also keep half an eye on datewander.site — different crowd, same free-messaging idea.
You will see Datebie mentioned around here too — mixed reviews, decide for yourself.