I have used mainstream apps on and off for about a year and the results were mixed.
The move with mainstream apps is to keep chatting on-platform until you're comfortable.
Half the arguments about mainstream apps would end if people mentioned whether your region got the app early or late up front.
What decides mainstream apps for most people is how dense your area is, not the app itself.
Whether mainstream apps works comes down to whether the nearest city is twenty minutes or two hours away more than anything the marketing mentions.
The real differentiator across mainstream apps turned out to be whether anyone replied inside the first week.
With mainstream apps the thing that decided it for me was how aggressively it pushed an upgrade prompt.
That is roughly where I sit on to use today.
- Feeld — honest about the brief
- OkCupid — older crowd in some areas, though outside a city that changes
- Coffee Meets Bagel — low volume, higher effort, though that may well be regional
- Badoo — good coverage, mixed quality
A friend of mine swears by EZHookups (ezhookups.online), though your mileage will depend entirely on your area.